Welcome to The Wagner Restaurant
Nestled in the heart of Penn Yan, The Wagner Restaurant is a cherished local gem known for its hearty diner fare and welcoming atmosphere. With a diverse menu featuring delectable wraps, comforting melts, and satisfying burgers, this eatery caters to every palate. Diners rave about the sweet-tinged buffalo chicken wrap and generous portions that promise fulfilling meals. The friendly and attentive staff ensure a delightful experience, making each visit memorable. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick breakfast or a leisurely lunch, The Wagner Restaurant embodies the essence of a classic diner where good food and good company come together beautifully.
-
124 E Elm St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States Hotline: +1 315-536-8062
Located in the heart of Penn Yan, NY, The Wagner Restaurant has become a beloved local gem, known for its warm atmosphere and comfort food that brings families and friends together. Situated at 124 E Elm St, this charming spot is a perfect blend of casual dining and satisfying flavors.
The menu at The Wagner Restaurant is an extensive homage to classic diner fare, featuring an array of mouthwatering options. Whether you're a fan of melts, burgers, or wraps, there's something to satisfy every palate. The standout items include:
- Wagner Melts: Tuna Melt, Chicken Melt, Club Melt, Roast Beef & Cheddar Melt, Pastrami Melt
- Burgers: Wagner Burger, Bacon Cheeseburger, Cheeseburger, Hamburger
- Wraps: Chicken Finger, Chicken Caesar, Tuna & Provolone, Buffalo Chicken Finger
Crowd favorite reviews from recent visitors reflect the quality of both the food and service. Kayla Pizura raved about the Buffalo Chicken Wrap, noting its delicious sweetness and generous portions. She appreciated the option of ranch instead of blue cheese, highlighting how customizable the meals can be. Meanwhile, Brian Reilly and Brittany Moore applauded the attentive staff, consistent great food, and reasonable prices that keep patrons returning.
The Wagner Restaurant is not just a place to eat; it's a community hub where friendly faces and hearty meals create lasting memories. If you’re looking to indulge in classic diner style with a twist, certainly try their diverse menu options. The atmosphere is inviting, making it an ideal spot to start your day — or take a break for lunch. The reviews tell a consistent story: delicious food, welcoming service, and a true taste of local flavor.
In a world of fleeting food trends, The Wagner Restaurant stands as a tribute to the joys of traditional diner cuisine, nestled perfectly in Penn Yan. You won’t just come for the food; you’ll leave with a smile, planning your next visit before you even take your last bite.
Came here for lunch on Wednesday and had the buffalo chicken wrap. It had a more sweet flavor then what I am used to with buffalo chicken but it was still so delicious and good. I got it with ranch on the inside instead of blue cheese. And I got fries as well. Very impressed and I would recommend and come back another time.
Great food, reasonable prices, friendly and attentive wait staff. Ample parking. Had breakfast there twice while visiting on a long weekend.
The Wagner is a local favorite for a reason! The service is always quick and friendly, with very attentive wait staff. The food comes quickly with generous portions and you'll likely be offered a drink refill before you've even had a chance to empty your cup. This is my go to for breakfast and I've never been disappointed!
Good breakfast and good service. Popular place.
Great location for breakfast. Service was really good. Food was great! Open early. I would definitely recommend this place.
A nice small down diner! Good coffee, great cinnamon rounds . Good mexican omelet. Friendly waiter! Visiting from out of town.
Best diner in Penn Yan. Good food. Nice people. Quick service. Great price
Old school worn-floor diner with generous portions and good service. Got breakfast here and it filled us up nicely. Talking real diner food and not haute cuisine.